|
A top agriculture economist says
U.S. ethanol policy is continuing to drive meat and poultry prices
higher, according to a Coalition for Balanced Food and Fuel release.
Preliminary results of an analysis
released today by Dr. Tom Elam, president of Farm Econ, at the
Annual Meat Conference concluding today in Nashville, Tenn.,
offered a preview of his soon-to-be-released study.
He estimates the cumulative costs
to the food industry of the renewable fuels program will be about
$100 billion from 2005-2010. The program mandates minimum ethanol
production and provides tax incentives for ethanol use.
As part of his analysis, Elam
compared what would have happened without the federal biofuels
program with what has happened. Among his key findings:
- Farm-level corn prices in 2008
would have averaged about $2.77 per bushel without the program.
Ethanol tax credits have added $1.33 per bushel, and may drive
corn prices to more than $5 a bushel in 2009.
- Without the biofuels program,
Elam estimates that 2008 ethanol production would have been 4.5
billion gallons, but the program has added at least 4.2 billion
gallons.
- Ethanol would have been $1.69
a gallon, but increased demand for corn and higher corn prices
are driving ethanol prices up and they are now 51 cents a gallon
higher than they would have been without the program.
- Approximately 76 million acres
of corn would have been harvested in 2007, but the program added
10.5 million acres.
- The biofuels program is, in
effect, a regressive tax on food production. The windfall gains
from the program go to a relatively small number of corn and
soybean producers who were already better off than the average
American.
Elam also detailed the direct
impact of increased input costs on the meat and poultry industry
and on consumers themselves. Among his findings:
- As a result of the program this
year's swine input costs are up $2.9 billion; costs to the broiler
industry are up $3.4 billion; turkey input costs are up $646
million; cattle input costs are up $2.24 billion; and dairy producer
input costs are up $2.7 billion.
- Translated into a cost-per-animal,
Elam estimated the costs at $38 per hog; 53 cents per chicken;
$3.40 per turkey; and $117.50 per fed beef animal.
"You cannot use the combined
grain crops of Australia and Indonesia for U.S. fuel and not
have an impact on corn, soybean and food prices," Elam said.
He said he expects food price inflation to rise 5 or 6 percent
in 2009.
He predicted that consumers,
especially lower income consumers, will downgrade the cuts of
meat they purchase and pay more attention to generics. "People
will shop more carefully," he said.
|